OTP SHOWS TO DATE
[name of show, artistic director(s), date opened]
1977-78
The Good Doctor, David Messer, June 1977
Plaza Suite, David Messer, April 1978
1978-79
6 Rms Riv Vu, Forest "Bud" East, Oct. 1978
Under Milk Wood, John David Lutz Dec. 1978
Ladies in Retirement, Amy G. Loomis, March 1979
Doctor Sganarelle, Ellie Burdett, May 1979
Hansel & Gretel, July 1979
1979-80
Jacques Brel is Alive & Well & Living in Paris (special benefit), Joy Wilkison, Aug. 1979
The Time of Your Life, Chuck Thompson, Sept 1979
Come Blow Your Horn, Nancy Lawrence, Nov. 1979
Candida, Amy G. Loomis, Feb. 1980
Fashion, Ellie Burnett April 1980
1980-81
Cabaret: 1940s Review, Aug. 1981
A Thousand Clowns, Nancy Lawrence, Sept. 1980
See How They Run, Linda King, Nov. 1980
The Zeal of Thy House, Amy G. Loomis, March 1981
1981-82
Cabaret: A Night at Miss Kitty's, Herb Schlotterbeck & Karen Campbell, Aug. 1981
(A) The Old Lady Shows Her Medals, David Messer, (B) A Phoenix Too Frequent, Amy Loomis, Dec. 1981
Journey to Jerusalem, Tom Low & Mary Jo Vermillion, Mar. 1982
The Mad Woman of Challiot, David Messer, April 1982
The Odd Couple, Linda King, June 1982
1982-83
Cabaret: An Evening with You in Mind, Becky Brockman, Becki Rettinger, & Jo Strader, Aug. 1982
The Royal Family, David Messer & Amy Loomis, Sept 1982
Starting Here, Starting Now, Paul Lane, Nov. 1982
California Suite, Jane & Kevin Kramer, Mar. 1983
Murder at Howard Johnson's, Terry McCraney, May 1983
1983-84
Cabaret: An Evening at the Vieux Carré, Aug. 1983
Second Shepherd's Play, Herb Schlotterbeck, Dec. 1983
Life with Father, Georgiann Shide, Jan. 1984
Death Trap, Dale Brockman, Mar. 1984
Kind Lady, Tom Low, May 1984
The Prime of Miss Jean Brody, June 1984
1984-85
Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dream Coat, Hubert Fryman & Tom Ruble, Sept. 1984
The Lady Who Cried Fox, Liz Richardson, Nov. 1984
Stalag 17, Terry McCraney, April 1985
A Night at Miss Kitty's, Herb Schlotterbeck & Karen Campbell, Aug 1985
1985-86
Cabaret: Broadway Along the Wabash, Tom Ruble, June 1985
Wild Flowering of Chastity, Mary Jo Vermillion, Sept. 1985
Once Upon a Mattress, Harold Truitt, Nov. 1985
Play it Again, Sam, Terry McCraney, Feb. 1986
The Dining Room, Mary Jo Vermillion, Apr. 1986
1986-87
Cabaret: A Night in Olde England
Agatha Christie Made Me Do It, Karen Campbell, Sept. 1986
On Golden Pond, Jack Mahoney, Nov. 1986
Of Mice & Men, Terry McCraney & John Rogers, Feb. 1987
Divorce, Southern Style, Duke & Kinga Low, May 1987
1987-88
Cabaret: The Ransom of Red Chief, John Rogers & Terry McCraney, Aug. 1987
Harvey, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1987
A Christmas Carol, Gene Biby, Dec. 1987
The Rainmaker, John Rogers, Feb. 1988
The Odd Couple (female), Terry McCraney, May 1988
1988-89
Cabaret: Selections of the 40's at the USO, Terry McCraney, Sept. 1988
The Nerd, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1988
Arsenic & Old Lace, John Rogers, Dec. 1988
A Hatful of Rain, Vickie Puffer, Mar. 1989
On Blue Mountain, Mary Jo Vermillion, May 1989
1989-90
Cabaret: Keep Peace With Your Soul, Karen Campbell, Sept. 1989
Love, Sex, & the IRS, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1989
Noises Off, Mary Jo Vermillion, Jan. 1990
The Diary of Anne Frank, Dane Phillips, Mar. 1990
1990-91
Cabaret: A Brand New Decade, Karen Campbell, Sept. 1990
Steel Magnolias, John Rogers, Oct. 1990
Guilty Conscience, Jack Mahoney, Dec. 1990
Ten Little Indians, Carol Phillippe, Mar. 1991
The Good Doctor, Lillian Klipsch, May 1991
1991-92
First Monday in October, Dale Brockman, Oct. 1991
(A) Boogey Down, Jack Mahoney, (B) The Long Christmas Dinner, Mary Jo Vermillion, Dec. 1991
Lysistrata, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 1992
Pinchpenny Phantom of the Opera, Mary Jo Vermillion, May 1992
1992-93
Cabaret: The New Broadway, Jack Mahoney, July 1992
The Prisoner of Second Avenue, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1992
Same Time, Next Year, Terry McCraney, Feb. 1993
A Streetcar Named Desire, Dane Phillips, Apr. 1993
(A) Beauty & the Beast, Carol Phillippe, (B) Charlotte's Web, Denise Hendrix, July 1993
1993-94
Cabaret: Dreaming of a New World, Aug. 1993
The Trip to Bountiful, John Rogers, Oct. 1993
Beyond Reasonable Doubt, Jack Mahoney, Dec. 1993
Barefoot in the Park, Robin Overbey, Feb. 1994
Boeing-Boeing, Joe Comer, April 1994
1994-95
Cabaret: An Evening at the Crystal Palace, Vickie Puffer, 1994
Wait Until Dark, Sally Perkins, Oct. 1994
I Take this Man, Robin Overbey, Dec. 1994
The Misanthrope, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 1995
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Dane Phillips, Apr. 1995
1995-96
Cabaret: The Caffeine Fix, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 1995
Bus Stop, Dane Phillips, Dec. 1995
Crimes of the Heart, Vickie Puffer, Feb. 1996
Scratch, Robin Overbey, Apr. 1996
P.S. Your Cat is Dead!, Meghan McFarland, June 1996
1996-97
A Few Good Men, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1996
Kringle's Window, Robin Overbey, Dec. 1996
A Thurber Carnival, Terry McCraney & John Rogers, Feb. 1997
Run for Your Wife, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 1997
Pinocchio, Alethea Gasser, June 1997
1997-98
Poe! Poe! Poe! & Dracula, Jack Mahoney, Oct. 1997
A Tuna Christmas, Linda Ostermeier, Dec. 1997
Mr. Riddles, Dane Phillips, Feb. 1998
Black Comedy, Meghan McFarland, Apr. 1998
1998-99
Cabaret: That's Amoré, Jack Mahoney, Aug. 1998
The Virginian, Terry McCraney, Sept. 1998
Sorry, Wrong Chimney, Robin Overbey, Nov. 1998
Funny Money, Vickie Puffer, Feb. 1999
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 1999
1999-00
Cabaret: Gypsies, Tramps & Thieves, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 1999
The Family Man, Robin Overbey, Oct. 1999
The Glass Menagerie, Dane Phillips, Dec. 1999
The Cemetery Club, John Rogers, Feb. 2000
The Sound of Music, Linda Ostermeier, Apr. 2000
2000-01
Cabaret: Shiver Me Timbers, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2000
Come Back to the Five & Dime, Jimmy Dean, Dale Brockman, Oct. 2000
It Runs in the Family, Dane Phillips, Dec. 2000
Ladies of the Mop & Greater Tuna, Linda Ostermeier, Feb. 2001
Moon Over Buffalo, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 2001
Annie, Linda Ostermeier, June 2001
2001-02
Cabaret: Jambalaya Gumbo, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2001
A Bad Year for Tomatoes, Robin Overbey, Nov. 2001
A Tuna Christmas, Linda Ostermeier, Dec. 2001
The Elephant Man, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 2002
Spinoff, Dan Reitmeyer, Apr. 2002
Love Rides the Rails, Vickie Puffer, May 2002
2002-03
Cabaret: Very Merry Men, Jack Mahoney, Aug. 2002
Rumors, Robin Overbey, Oct. 2002
The Miracle Worker, Jack Mahoney, Dec. 2002
Blithe Spirit, John Rogers, Feb. 2003
To Kill a Mockingbird, Dane Phillips, Apr. 2003
Chase Me, Comrade, Vickie Puffer, May 2003
2003-04
The King & I, Robin Overbey, Aug. 2003
A Star on the Door, Robin Overbey, Oct. 2003
Who's Under Where?, Vickie Puffer, Dec. 2003
A Night of Greek Classics: Oedipus & Antigone, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 2004
Bargains, Dan Reitmeyer, Apr. 2004
Man of LaMancha, Jack Mahoney, June 2004
2004-05
Cabaret: Grapes of Wrath County, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2004
The Odd Couple, Robin Overbey, Nov. 2004
Morning’s at Seven, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 2005
Arsenic & Old Lace, Joy Neighbors, Apr. 2005
Caught in the Net, Vickie Puffer, May 2005
Cinderella, Robin Overbey, July 2005
2005-06
Cabaret: Pistols & Petticoats, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2005
Jeckyl & Hyde, Terry Cox, Nov. 2005
Because Their Hearts Were Pure, Vickie Puffer, Feb. 2006
The Front Page, Joy Neighbors, Mar. 2006
Lend Me a Tenor, Robin Overbey, June 2006
2006-07
OTP Follies Talent Show, Robin Overbey, Aug. 2006
Cabaret: Hipflasks & Peepholes, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2006
Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol: A Traveling Travesty in 2 Tumultuous Acts, Robin Overbey, Nov. 2006
Boy Meets Girl, Robin Overbey, Feb. 2007
A Murder is Announced, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 2007
The Man Who Came to Dinner, Jack Mahoney, June 2007
2007-08
Cabaret: Shamrocks & Shenanigans, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2007
Our Town, Tom Compton, Oct. 2007
An American Millionaire, Jason Keller, Dec. 2007
Kiss or Make Up, Robin Overbey, Feb. 2008
Sylvia, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 2008
Bye Bye Birdie, Robin Overbey, June 2008
2008-09
Cabaret: Carnival Capers, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2008
The Sunshine Boys, Jason Keller, Oct. 2008
Dearly Beloved, Jack Mahoney, Jan. 2009
See How They Run, Vickie Puffer, Mar. 2009
Squabbles, Jack Mahoney, May 2009
Gypsy, Robin Overbey, July 2009
2009-10
Nunsense, Linda Ostermeier, Sept. 2009
Christmas Belles, Jack Mahoney, Nov. 2009
Barefoot in the Park, Robin Overbey, Feb. 2010
The Curious Savage, Vickie Puffer, Apr, 2010
South Pacific, Robin Overbey, June 2010
2010-11
Cabaret: Beware the Mummy’s Tale, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2010
Frankenstein, Jason Keller, Oct. 2010
Humbug, Vickie Puffer, Dec. 2010
Southern Hospitality, Jack Mahoney, Feb. 2011
I Hate Hamlet, Darrell Wolven, Apr, 2011
Something’s Afoot, Vickie Puffer, July 2011
2011-12
Cabaret: Medieval Malarkey, Jack Mahoney, Sept 2011
The Haunting of Hill House, Jason Keller, Oct. 2011
Dashing Through the Snow, Jack Mahoney, Dec. 2011
Play It Again, Sam, Darrell Wolven, Feb. 2012
Red, White & Tuna, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 2012
Happy Days: The Musical, Steve Gray & Jack Mahoney, July 2012
2012-13
Cabaret: Great Balls of Fire, Jack Mahoney, Sept. 2012
Dracula, Jason Keller, Oct. 2012
The Nerd, Bill Simmons & Jack Mahoney, Dec. 2012
The Red Velvet Cake War, Vickie Puffer, Feb. 2013
Moving Mountains, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 2013
Blame It On the Movies, Vickie Puffer, June 2013
2013-14
Night of the Living Dead, Jason Keller, Oct. 2013
Cabaret: A Steampunk Holiday Adventure, Jack Mahoney, Dec. 2013
Deathtrap, Steve Gray, Feb. 2014
Nunsensations!, Paula Morgan Martin, Apr. 2014
The Music Man, Jack Mahoney, Craig Johnson, June 2014
2014-15
Cabaret: The Caffeine Fix, Jack Mahoney, Aug. 2014
Sweeney Todd, Jason Keller, Oct. 2014
A Christmas Story, Steve Gray, Dec. 2014
Fox on the Fairway, Craig Johnson, Feb. 2015
Steel Magnolias, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 2015
The Jungle Book, Zane Grogan, June 2015
2015-16
Assisted Living, Vickie Puffer, Aug. 2015
Sleepy Hollow, Jason Keller, Oct. 2015
Best Christmas Pageant Ever / Gift of the Magi, Steve Gray, Dec. 2015
Farce of Nature, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 2016
Sleeping Beauty, Vickie Puffer, June 2016
2016-17
Making God Laugh, John Rogers, June 2016
Poe’s Midnight Dreary, Bill Simmons, Oct. 2016
Charlie Brown Christmas / Soapy Smith’s Christmas Wish, Steve Gray, Dec. 2016
Dearly Departed, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 2017
The Enchantment of Beauty and the Beast, Vickie Puffer, June 2017
2017-18
The Pink Panther Strikes Again, Jack Mahoney, Aug. 2017
Of Mice & Men, Bill Simmons, Oct. 2017
The Grunch, Kathy Mooney, Dec. 2017
Rex's Exes, Vickie Puffer, Apr. 2018
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, Mark Snyder, June 2018
2018-19
Moonglow, Coni Like Webber, Aug. 2018
12 Incompetent Jurors, Billy Simmons, Oct. 2018
A Friend From Afar, Steve Gray, Dec. 2018
The Elves & the Shoemaker, Steve Gray, Dec. 2018
Vintage Hitchcock, Craig Johnson, Apr. 2019
Gilligan’s Island: The Musical, Vickie Puffer, June 2019
2019-20
On Golden Pond, Coni Like Webber Aug. 2019
Plan 9 from Outer Space, Steve Gray, Oct. 2019
Assisted Living: THE HOME for the Holidays, Vickie Puffer, Dec. 2019
2020-21
Four Old Broads, Coni Like Webber, Aug. 2020
The Addams Family, Catena Minnich, Oct. 2020
May the Farce Be With You, Billy Simmons, Feb. 2021
The Beverly Hillbillies, Jack Mahoney, Apr. 2021
2021-2022
Young Frankenstein, Catena Minnich, Oct. 2021
Miracle on 34th Street, Coni Like Webber, Dec. 2021
All Shook Up, Vickie Puffer, April 2022
Clue: On Stage, Steven Gray, June 2022
2022-2023
OTP Follies Talent Showcase, Robin Overbey, August 2022
10 Ways To Survive The Zombie Apocalypse & The Best Haunted House Ever!, Bill Simmons, October 2022
A Christmas Carol & The Grouch, Vickie Puffer, December 2022
Four Weddings & An Elvis, Craig Johnson, April 2023
The Inn At Rose Harbor, Coni Like-Webber, June 2023
2023-2024
OTP Follies Talent Showcase, Robin Overbey, August 2023
Something Wicked This Way Comes, Jason Keller, October 2023
A Christmas Story, Steve Gray, December 2023
Lickety Split, Jack Mahoney, April 2024
Grumpy Old Men, Vickie Puffer, June 2024
2024-2025
Rock of Ages, Coni Like-Webber, August 2024
Wait Until Dark, Vickie Puffer, October 2024
Kringle's Window, Steve Gray, December 2024
Our Town, Tom Compton, April 2025
OTP Follies Talent Showcase, Robin Overbey, June 2025